SOUTH AFRICA'S TV WEBSITE
SIGN IN SEARCH MENU
SOUTH AFRICA'S TV WEBSITE


Idols 15: Top 4 live show - what the judges said

Written by TVSA Team from the blog Mzansi Magic on 27 Oct 2019
Favourite this post



Yawn. The plot didn't thicken, sicken nor progress on Idols on Sunday (27 October) when no-one was eliminated after last week's Twexit.

The Top 4 knew they were safe for another week and sang two high school hits each.

Here's a recap of the judges' comments by Mzansi Magic in case you missed the show:

Nolo Seodisha

Nolo was first to perform with his mother’s favourite song during her high school days, Let’s Groove by Earth, Wind and Fire and returned later to perform Bruno Mars’ Lazy Song. 

The judges were pleased with his first performance, with Randall calling it great and Unathi saying he killed it.

Somizi wished he had added that something extra by researching the song, but said this did not take away from the good performance.

Unathi said his second performance was charming, while Somizi called it cute. Randall said he was more engaged this week than in other weeks, which he reckoned would count in his favour.

Micayla Oelofse

Micayla started with her dad’s favourite song, It Must Have Been Love by Roxette, which was pleasant enough for the judges, but it was her performance of Ariana Grande’s Dangerous Woman that had them raving.

It was a powerful performance,” said Unathi, while Somizi said it was beautiful. Randall said it was clear that this was the type of music she enjoyed and was comfortable with.

Luyolo Yiba

Luyolo performed his parents’ high school favourite hit, Night Shift by The Commodores and the judges called it a phenomenal tribute to the Motown greats.

But it was his second performance that blew them away. Channeling his inner Usher, his rendition of R&B superstar’s OMG had Randall blustering “Who is this guy?” and commending him for his excellent choice of songs.

Unathi said it was a popping and amazing performance, while Somizi gave him his biggest “whoo shem”.

Sneziey Msomi

Sneziey has been getting the lion’s shares of Somizi's “whoo shems” across the competition and she maintained this with her first song as Somizi dished out his ultimate expression of praise for her performance of Brenda Fassie’s Umuntu Ngabantu.

Randall was impressed that she'd paid tribute to the late great MaBrrr by not only learning the song, but also learning the performance. Unathi said she didn't think it was possible for her to outperform her showstopper performance, yet she did it.

Her second song, Bucie’s Superwoman, didn't get the same response. The judges said it proved she was only human because they weren't sold on the performance.

While Somizi said it was OK to offramp now and again, Randall reminded her that as the show was getting closer to the end, the other contestants were upping their game.
 
----

One must be voted out next week. And 3 will go to New York as they prepare for the Top 2.

----
 
Did you agree with the judges' comments or did you feel like you were watching a different show from them?
 

Shows in this post: Idols

Channels in this post: Mzansi Magic



Comments


Only TVSA members can reply to this thread. Click here to login or register.






LATEST ARTICLES

Bloedspoor Teasers - October 2025

There's a body in a car and Ilgaz is sure that Cinar is hiding something.


New on TV today: Tuesday 16 September 2025

The Last Rhinos: A New Hope airs on Disney+ and BBC Earth follows cutting-edge surgeons in a new series.


2025 Emmy Awards: Biggest snub, biggest win, biggest eyeroll

We love it when a plan comes together. A wrap of the wins in key categories and our special awards.


Scandal! Teasers - October 2025

Ephraim's woes at the butchery continue when a helper is put under pressure to sabotage him.


New on TV today: Monday 15 September 2025

The 2025 Emmy Awards air live and repeated on M-Net and Welcome to Plathville returns to TLC.


New on TV today: Sunday 14 September 2025

Celebrity Race Across the World returns on BBC Earth and Home Channel fires up Jamie's Easy Meals for Every Day.


New on TV today: Saturday 13 September 2025

TLC weighs in with 1000-lb Roomies and The Mommy Club 3 arrives to terrorise Mzansi Magic.


On Carte Blanche: illegal cigarettes smoke out South Africa

Blast back to lockdown when illegal cigarettes were all the rage. Now they're outselling legal ones.


Blink Kant Bo 2 Teasers - October 2025

Orhan faces abuse in prison as Pelin fights for her life when she goes into labour.


New on TV today: Friday 12 September 2025

Netflix unpacks the Beauty and the Bester and BBC Brit presents Freddie Flintoff's Field of Dreams.

LATEST SITE ACTIVITY


More activity at TVSA Central



,

LATEST SOAPIE TEASERS


,

LATEST SOAPIE TEASERS




×
×

You browser doesn't have Flash, Silverlight, Gears, BrowserPlus or HTML5 support.