SOUTH AFRICA'S TV WEBSITE
SIGN IN SEARCH MENU
SOUTH AFRICA'S TV WEBSITE


IDOLS 4: Top 10

Written by Amazingly from the blog Idolwise on 15 Oct 2007
Favourite this post


After recording this weeks episode, I switched on the TV at the precise moment where Gareff Cliff was prophesizing over Jody's future; and decided there and then that I would watch the program and NOT listen to a single thing the judges say. 

That way I can make up my own mind about the performances and as a bonus, I don't have to listen to Gareffs musings. 

My thoughts: Brief, for once. 

Munro : I suppose he could sing twinkle twinkle and I would still love him. I think he did extremely well, started a bit slow but towdally rocked after that! A firm fav of mine and I've already oted a few times for him. 

Daniel : Sanjaya's second cousin. The vocals weren't too strong but I enjoyed it. He's just so cute, you can't help but like him. Would definately like to see  much more him. 

Yolanda : Not confident and it came through in her song and actions. Her vocals were just too weak and she's in my bottom 3 this week. 

Tender : I loved her performance. Not oversung and did not continuously play for the camera. Right on the money!

Dominic : I don't even want to comment. Was just too painful to watch. Shame man. Into the bottom 3 you go.

Andriette : I was sceptical because I'm not a Celine Dion fan but she was very VERY good. I like her because she has a unique tone to her voice and she can hold all her notes. Unlike some other contestants...

Caroline : I like her energy and her vibe. May not be the strongest vocally, but she has something about her that i absolutely adore. 

Bjorn: I thought Bjorn sounded very good but I don't like the way he comes across. He's way too arrogant. There's a difference between confidence and arrogance and he has crossed the line. And that walk, he thinks it's a strut but it's more like a waddle. Smarten up boytjie, people don't like braggarts. You can go far if you don't overplay it. 

Carla : Carla, Carla, Carla. She looked spastic at times and I wasn't enjoying that throaty screeching at all. Especially those first 2 opening ones. Nothing about her performance was good. Up to and including those yellow shoes. Bottom 3 chick. 

Jody :  OK - what's with all the Jody overkill?
Maybe it's because I simply hate the song she sang but I DO NOT GET IT.

When Gareff gets that oh-wise-one look on his face, I truly want to hurl. Preferably hurl something at his head. And that cryptic comment about her going to win and him not wanting her to. Message to Gareff: Better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to speak out and remove all doubt. 

I  like Jody, I really do. I just don't think that performance was all that. 

Oh, and I LOVE the new set. It looks absolutely fab and the contestants used it to the best of their ability.

Which reminds me. Please shoot their choreographer. Some waddled, others flayed their arms about and one was having spastic fits on that beautiful new stage. They have enough problems with choosing perfect songs, remembering lyrics and acid judges and don't need to worry about crappy dance moves. 

NOW VOTE PEOPLE:  Remember that you can't complain about who wins if you don't cast your 2 cents as well!

YOLANDA - 086 22 777 01
DOMINIC  - 086 22 777 02
TENDER  - 086 22 777 03
ANDRIETTE  - 086 22 777 06
CAROLINE  - 086 22 777 08
DANIEL   -  086 22 777 09
JODY  - 086 22 777 11
MUNRO - 086 22 777 12
CARLA - 086 22 777 13 
BJORN   - 086 22 777 14










8 Comments

Racey
15 Oct 2007 03:07

I'm not enjoying this season of idols at all and feel so guilty for making my poor husband listen to a group of wannabe singers singing soooooooo badly! It's terrible! Pass me the ear plugs pleeeeeeez!  There may be 1 or 2 ppl on that show who could maybe sing but the rest ..... please vote them ALL out this week and put us out of our misery! And can some one please teach those crappy bunch of judges what a GOOD singer sounds like and how to comment and give constructive criticism ! Sigh ....

Dimago
15 Oct 2007 03:35

I'm really not inspired by anyone in the show. So much so that i only watch if there's really nothing else to do. I may wait until top 5, maybe there'll be some serious singing then.

so i wont be voting, i'll rely on your recaps Ama...

zo
15 Oct 2007 04:16

racey i am with u, this seasons idols remind of west african idols, i used to moan abt how bad they were. my god, and if Mara cries again over Jody i am going to commit suicide

Amazingly
15 Oct 2007 04:53

>>and if Mara cries again over Jody i am going to commit suicide<<
HEE - no need to be that drastic - but i agree, their fawning over Jody is positively eyestabbingly painful to watch!

And once the amateurs have been seperated from the pro's then i'm sure we'll have a real competition on our hands.

i see no front runners though.............


Paralyzer
15 Oct 2007 05:30

I have nothing against Jody, but she is not the best singer, SORRY!!!I just don't like the tone of her voice!! I am rooting for Tender and Andriette!!

Spy
15 Oct 2007 05:42

I would just like to say I really proud to be in this forum where people tell it like it is.  I thought i was going crazy.  But i honestly do not like Jody.  Mara is ofcourse doing what she knows best and acting her crying scenes!  There is nothing to cry over.  She is not that AMAZING!!!!! Honestly.

As for the whole show I TOTALLY agree with Racey. We dont have anyone spectacular this year and the show just doesnt have singers at all - but lets work with what we've got.

I really think Tender is great.  Andriette is also great.  I like Bjorn - always have but he must watch it.  Caroline is a good singer but must listen to Randall's advise.   Munro ROCKS!!!!! Love him to bits - he reminds of the lead singer in Nickelback.   Yolanda or Dominic must go home.  Carla must STOP TRYING TO BE CUTE  ALL THE TIME!  She is over 4yrs old - its NOT CUTE ANYMORE!!!!!!!!!!!

MegaB
15 Oct 2007 07:37

Totally agree with u guys, yesterday i was wondering: Is it just me who diesnt like that Jody girl, and i mean Garreth saying she was gona win ... i was thinking someone shoot me. She is not all that AT ALL. Muro rocks!!! 
i absolutely hate that carla girl!!!!! but all in all i think Tender is this year's idol!

pawagie
16 Oct 2007 03:40

love caroline nomatter what


Only TVSA members can reply to this thread. Click here to login or register.






LATEST ARTICLES

New on TV today: Wednesday 8 May 2024

It's a day for the streamers with new shows on Apple TV+, Disney+ and Netflix.


kykNET and Showmax call for TV show and film proposals

Genres they're looking to commission include drama, reality, documentary and feature films.


Uzalo Teasers - June 2024

Another police station gets robbed, the church has a new drum player and Nkunzi’s has an emotional fit.


New on TV today: Tuesday 7 May 2024

Netflix follows the Super Rich in Korea as BBC Earth documents The Battle to Beat Malaria.


Top Shows on TV: April 2024

The Masked Singer SA 2 delivers a high note for S3 but Wheel of Fortune is nowhere to be seen.


Come Back To Me Teasers - June 2024

The new president of the Zepeda Group has 48 hours to fix things.


New on TV today: Monday 6 May 2024

e.tv's new novela Kelders van Geheime begins as Comedy Central gets Out of Order.


New on TV today: Sunday 5 May 2024

The SA Sport Awards air live on SABC1 and two reality shows return to Mzansi Magic.


New on TV today: Saturday 4 May 2024

Call the Bailiffs begins on CBS Reality and Star Wars: Tales of the Empire drops on Disney+.


New! Kelders van Geheime Teasers - May 2024

Nothing like a Will to bring a family together. NOT. Soebatskloof farm is a ticking time bomb on e.tv's new 18h00 local show.

LATEST SITE ACTIVITY


More activity at TVSA Central



LATEST SOAPIE TEASERS



LATEST SOAPIE TEASERS





×
×

You browser doesn't have Flash, Silverlight, Gears, BrowserPlus or HTML5 support.