SOUTH AFRICA'S TV WEBSITE
SIGN IN SEARCH MENU
SOUTH AFRICA'S TV WEBSITE


Get your reviews and insights on everything to do with movies and TV, locally and internationally.

Movie Review: Star Wars - The Rise of Skywalker

Written by tha - bang from the blog Movies and Things with Thabang on 20 Jan 2020
Favourite this post


Star Wars - The Rise of Skywalker has proven once and for all that fan service is killing popular culture, film and television.

From GoT’s final season to DC’s Justice League and now to Star Wars - The Rise of Skywalker we've seen how studios and creatives are trying to please the fan boys of the franchises first and foremost, instead of putting their efforts into telling a compelling story.

This has resulted in a Frankenstein’s monster of final editions of beloved franchises that lack a cohesive creative take or element of risk taking.

Let's dig into a very spoilery dive into Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker:

 
I should declare upfront that I’m one of the few Star Wars fans who actually loved The Last Jedi. Yes, I thought Rian Johnson killing Snoke was unearned and not cool.

I didn’t like the light sabre toss at the beginning but I loved that Rian had an idea he stuck by - it was encapsulated by the immortal words of Kylo Ren: “Let the past die, kill it if you must.’’
 
Rian was willing to let Star Wars break away from being beholden to the original trilogy and prequel mythology. He started carving new ground: it ended with Rey as the definite heir apparent to the Jedi mantel and Kylo Ren as the heir apparent to the big bad guy role.  

Now, the question was: how will this play out?... enter JJ Abrams with Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker… and a lot of potential was squandered. Why?


 

Star Wars fanboys.

They were up in arms with most of the changes that Rian brought, including giving Finn a love interest outside from the trio in Rose Tico (and it didn’t help the fan boy that Rose Tico is of Asian ancestry and not white).

The other big issue was that Rian dared to challenge the concept of what a hero means today instead of aping George Lucas' 1970s ideals… How dare he.

So JJ Abrams, the man who gave the fanboys a facsimile of A New Hope / The Force Awakens was given another chance to pander to the fanboys and give them what they want… narrative sense and continuation of themes be damned!
 
So JJ gives the fanboys the Kylo Ren helmet back (even though TLJ had addressed why he needed to move on from the Darth Vader fan boy helmet).

The fanboys liked the Knight of Ren...well, JJ brings them back but you know as much about them at the end of this movie as we did in TFA… akere it's not about story or character development but about the Knights of Ren looking cool. They are a plot device.


 
JJ gives you more light sabre battles, more planets, more creatures and more retconning of legacy characters that are shoe-horned in the last film... 'cause why? - it will get the fan boys going.

The mentality: let's shoe-horn the emperor 'cause it will get the fan going…never mind that it doesn't make narrative sense to bring in “this surprise” in the closing chapter of a trilogy.
 
But what happens to story: the story suffers. Many of the threads from The Last Jedi and even The Force Awakens are not built on.

Instead JJ and the writing team decide to create their own movie that needs to be set-up within the first hour of the movie and paid off in the last hour by ignoring mostly what happened in TLJ .

The closing chapter of the trilogy ignores the mid-chapter - yes, that’s what happens.
 
We get a new big bad… who was never hinted at all in the previous two movies.

We get new information about legacy characters that did not exist in the original Star Wars trilogy nor the pre-equals or extended materials or even the animated series but hey, who cares? The fans will go wild for Palpatine being back all of a sudden…wow.


 
Then we have bits from other movies that are re-done and the repetition comes to the same fight being repeated over and over.

The sad part is that there's a powerful story in The Rise of Skywalker about identity, family and self-acceptance that is drowned out by JJ trying to score points by making fans happy which means the plot misses its own story.
 
The story suffers so much that even one of the fundamental ideas introduced in The Force Awakens around Vader's legacy is never answered.

Kylo models himself on Vader but Anakin never shows up to have a heart-to-heart with his grandson. Instead we have a Man of Steel motif ripped off very badly with Han Solo being brought back.

The film suffers from too many fake-outs that come across as playing chicken, unwilling to do gutsy things with characters like letting Chewbacca die or letting C3PO have his memory wiped out to give the movie some real emotional and tangible stakes.




At least the movie is not entirely all bad. No, it's definitely not the final season of Game of Thrones or Justice League bad... there are charming characters like Babu Frik, some great looking planets and sets but it doesn't begin to touch the heights of The Last Jedi or even Rogue One.

The saga ends on a whimper. You need to be under 10 to thoroughly enjoy what JJ has done with the last film - that’s how insulting it is.
 
It's not terrible, it has great visuals, some cool ideas, some potential character developments but the story is weak from execution and development.

It’s stuffed with a too many incidents that don’t cohesively gel within the trilogy itself… I hope Kennedy has learned her lesson that being too beholden to fans does not make for a good story.

A good story has its own reward and there's nothing wrong with taking a risk and making fans cry and hurt.
 
What it felt like: JJ was giving the middle finger to Rian Johnson and he thought the force was so strong with the fan boy base that we won't see that the emperor is naked or that Disney has produced a B-Grade movie with millions of dollars.

This is an indictment on Kathleen Kennedy's stewardship of this trilogy and an end to the hero worshipping of JJ Abrams.
 
 
Rating
**
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* trash **you are on you own ***its good ****almost perfect *****instant classic
 
 

Actors in this post: Adam Driver, John Boyega



2 Comments

Tashi
23 Jan 2020 10:53

Tashi edited on
1/23/2020 10:55 AM

Very true what you say Thabang, it's like many writers and creators have a million voices in their heads, especially since the advent of Twitter.

I noticed it bigtime with Ricky Gervais' Netflix stand-up comedy show Humanity - it was as if he'd written to pacify Twitter.

He also mentions Twitter in the show, which emphasised its influence. It wasn't nearly as good as I expected it would be because of this.

It was a different story with his comedy series After Life though - it's excellent because he isn't himself in it but rather a character.

The character clearly gave him more artistic license and "protection" against being personally attacked on Twitter for what he has to say. 

 

tha - bang
28 Jan 2020 09:07

its sad , viewers as co-creators is supposed to enrich the work but as you say Tashi its resulting in too many voices in the writers and creatives head and the work is suffering


Only TVSA members can reply to this thread. Click here to login or register.






LATEST ARTICLES

Game of Lies Teasers - April 2024

Series finale! The rescue attempt gets underway before a final reckoning.


Gqeberha: The Empire 2 Teasers - April 2024

The Mxenge Hotel turns into a whodunnit. A gunshot. Murder. In which room and by who?


The Wife 3 Teasers - April 2024

Naledi’s sex tape sees the spotlight again and catches her in the headlights.


Skerpioen Teasers - April 2024

A torched boat, poison in wine and youthful memories die when Ferda tries to kill Ahmet.


Imlie Teasers - April 2024

Imlie takes Ashu to the hospital when he falls ill, but kidnappers attempt to abduct him.


My Desire Teasers - April 2024

Kaashvi clears her name and reports Pradyumna's bribery attempt to the police.


New on TV today: Thursday 28 March 2024

Season 2 of Dam premieres on M-Net and Grey's Anatomy 20 drops on Disney+.


Hlomla Dandala confirmed to debut as Caesar on Smoke & Mirrors Season 2

The past collides with soon in the latest on Hlomla's whereabouts.


Smoke & Mirrors Teasers - April 2024

Season 1 finale and crossover alert! Caesar takes Thandiswa to the House of Zwide for her wedding dress.


Smoke & Mirrors 2 Teasers - April 2024

Season 2 premiere! Caesar's dark suspicions unravel as he demands the truth from Thandiswa.

LATEST SITE ACTIVITY


More activity at TVSA Central



LATEST SOAPIE TEASERS



LATEST SOAPIE TEASERS




Thabang Phetla loves movies,
he loves TV...
he loves his writing...
if you love movies and tv
you will definitely love
his writing on movies and TV.
signed by Thabang's Mom
 
×
×

You browser doesn't have Flash, Silverlight, Gears, BrowserPlus or HTML5 support.