SOUTH AFRICA'S TV WEBSITE
SIGN IN SEARCH MENU
SOUTH AFRICA'S TV WEBSITE


AI 9 Recap: Top 3 Claim Their Fame

Written by Tashi from the blog American Idol 9 on 17 May 2010
Favourite this post


Please note: this is about the latest episode of American Idol on M-Net so if you're watching on M-Net Series it includes spoilers for this weeks show - you may wish to return once the episode's been on. xoxo

final_four_large

casey_large

So. He's made it. Casey has somehow managed to shove himself into the Top 3 and it's completely inexplicable how or why. Along with Crystal and Lee, he's visiting his hometown this week - his hair glowing in praise and parades which shouldn't be for him.

I'm not gonna go on about how ludicrous it is except to say that now I'm very concerned. It seemed impossible that he could win BUT it was also impossible that he's made it to the end - so any madness is feasible. Imagine the size of the joke the season will be if it happens!

No, no, no. Lee has to win. I know Crystal's excellent but Lee's better. The reason: more girls will vote than guys so rooting for him is an insurance policy against rooting for the wrong voice.

Also, his lopsided smile and hair are both slurpier, which goes a looong way when it comes to such things. Which Crystal agrees with obviously.

I was thrilled (and surprised) to see how crushed on him she is - 'spesh when they flashed shots of that sloppy boyfriend of hers in between, hovering.

She mentioned that she has a musical crush on Lee, which isn't possible: a crush on one aspect of someone is always a crush on all of them - which she isn't able to openly admit in front of everyone natch.

All she could do to reveal her true feelings was deliver light touches in between her sparkly-eyed smiles to him.

crystal_lee_large

As the judges ruled: each of their duets were a gazillion times better than their solo performances, reflecting their sense of self-doubt once again. Even Big Mike and Casey managed to make their oddball relationship seem convincing in between the bizarre, solo song choices.

For the first time I missed Aaron - if he'd been around he definitely would have done Celine Dion's Titanic. He was always so willing to try the impossible, which none of the final four even vaguely attempted to do. They kept it too safe and none of them truly performed.

They hide behind their guitars instead of letting rip in the biggest way possible. They also refuse to listen to their mentors.

When Jamie Foxx told them that they need to Let Go, it felt as if he was speaking to a brick wall. It's exactly what they need to do to deliver us an exciting showdown, yet my money's on: they won't. There are only so many times you can mutter on about the same thing without it sticking.

As for what's what this week: the three will each be performing two songs to make the Final 2 - one of their own choice and one selected by the judges. The judges choices have been revealed, they are:

Crystal:  Maybe I'm Amazed by Paul McCartney - chosen by Ellen
Lee: Hallelujah by Leonard Cohen- chosen by Simon
Casey: Daughters by John Mayer - chosen by Randy and Kara

idol facts

Big Mike's elimination goes to show that when you fear something, it inevitably happens. He wanted to make the Top 3 and was so nervous that it wouldn't happen, it didn't.

It's better for the gym he belongs to that he didn't make it.

big_mike_large

If Crystal wins, she musn't commit to her boyfriend - it would be a huge mistake.

Simon Cowell really is leaving the show. I was hoping it's a hoax or that he'd change his mind, but neither has materialised.

It's better for musos to be less glam 'cos they age much better: as proven by Bon Jovi. Compare him to Mick Jagger and you'll see what I mean.

bon_jovi_large

mick_jagger_large



5 Comments

Savanah Dry
17 May 2010 11:07

Eish was sad to See Big Mike Go he was actually better than Casey i must say this season wasnt all that , the final three all seem shy for some reason !!!

And oh i thought i was the only one who noticed Bon Jovi , was asking my sister that we grew up listening to his music and now he looks like he is only 40 how old is he anyway!!!

Irene
17 May 2010 12:02

I'm hoping for a Crystal and Lee final - crossing all my fingers and toes. I thought BonJovi was brilliant - sigh. I must admit that I did root for Casey in the beginning, but as the season progressed I've changed my mind and now am feverishly hoping for a C&L final. And sorry Tashi, my money's on Crystal - she's been the only one that has been consistent throughout and defs deserves that win. I just love her and have been rooting for her since the start of the series.

Teeza
17 May 2010 13:10

I enjoy Casey's understated voice. It might just be a Casey&Lee finale!!!

TerryN
18 May 2010 07:39

Casey has somehow managed to shove himself into the Top 3 and it's completely inexplicable how or why. 

LMAO...
hey u can say that again Tashi...shood have been BIG MIKE on that Top 3, mxim!

LeatitiaPri
18 May 2010 12:54

i predicted the final 3 the way it is now
final 2 will be Lee & Crystal.
Crystal has been my favourite right from the start.  I would like for her to vote but I  must say Lee is also very good.


Only TVSA members can reply to this thread. Click here to login or register.






LATEST ARTICLES

New on TV today: Wednesday 6 August 2025

Nat Geo sets about Naming the Dead and Ugembula Ngathi deals with gambling on Mzansi Magic.


New! Uzozisola - Regrets Teasers - August 2025

A tease of e.tv's first isiZulu-dubbed Indian novela about the impact of betrayal.


New on TV today: Tuesday 5 August

BBC Earth shows you Just One Thing as SABC2 attempts to solve the Crime Scene Kitchen.


SuperSport calls for presenters and commentators in MVP Talent Search

Slam Dunk! the auditions and land a spot covering your fave sport.


Sweet Diva Teasers - August 2025

Maria faces sabotage when she enters a baking reality low and Jô gets fired again and again.


New on TV today: Monday 4 August 2025

Snake Catcher: Down Under slithers onto TLC and King of the Hill is revived by Disney+ after 15 years.


Skemergrond crystal ball: two first dates, sabotage and deeper motives

What does Fabian WANT? Gloria's suspicious. A companion to this month's key storylines.


New on TV today: Sunday 3 August 2025

Nat Geo Wild meanders down Croatia's Coast and Food Network cooks up two seasons of Must Try Asia.


Suidooster crystal ball: Nazeem stars in Fatal Attraction

He thinks he's seeing Laylla but... she's someone else. Six Xtras on this month's storylines.


New on TV today: Saturday 2 August 2025

Nat Geo Wild documents Death at the River and two shark-ey docs debut on Discovery's Shark Week.

LATEST SITE ACTIVITY


More activity at TVSA Central



,

LATEST SOAPIE TEASERS



,

LATEST SOAPIE TEASERS





×
×

You browser doesn't have Flash, Silverlight, Gears, BrowserPlus or HTML5 support.