SOUTH AFRICA'S TV WEBSITE
SIGN IN SEARCH MENU
SOUTH AFRICA'S TV WEBSITE


Why Drum will not apologise to Bonang

Written by makisto from the blog Frankly Speaking on 05 Mar 2013
Favourite this post


The Drum magazine will not be apologising to Bonang Matheba any time soon if not ever. The magazine was found guilty by the Press Ombudsman for publishing medical records the magazine claimed where about “an abortion of a woman fitting Bonang’s age and description” and alleging she is doing drugs as per their source’s claim without doing anything to verify the allegation, according to the Press Ombudsman’s findings. However, Bonang made it very clear she never had an abortion and is now suing the magazine, wants the magazine to apologise on their cover as per the ombudsman’s instruction.



Despite being found guilty for publishing the so called medical records, the magazine has no intention of apologising. “The editor is fighting the ombudsman’s ruling and took the matter to the magazine’s lawyers to look at and see what they can do. It does not make sense that the magazine should apologise whereas Bonang says the medical records are not hers,” says my source. Another source of mine adds. “The article never said Bonang had an abortion, the article stated the woman who had an abortion fitted Bonang’s description.” But the ombudsman found the magazine guilty, surely the office deserves the respect it should get especially in the wake of the whole Media Appeals Tribunal push if it passes, journalists will be arrested for making mistakes. Wouldn’t it be better if the magazine apologised and got the whole thing over and done with? I put this to my source. “Hell no! The editor doesn’t want to apologise because as much as Bonang says the medical records are not hers, the woman who leaked the records was fired. Immediately that makes one wonder why the woman would get fired if the medical records are not hers,” says my source.

My source further alleges Bonang doesn’t want the media to be writing about what she went through last year and only wants them to forever write about how she is now on Top Billing adding you cannot tell the media what to write about.

“Listen man, it is better if the magazine pays Bonang a lot of money than apologise. Imagine what that will do to the brand that the magazine is,” says my third source. But the whole article was also damaging to Bonang’s brand. “You speak like you are not a journalist. The media’s job is to write news and cannot be seen to be favouring certain public figures,” says the source.

“This whole issue is now being handled by the lawyers of the two parties and hopefully an agreement will be reached. Obviously the magazine is avoiding this matter to be taken to court and is prepared to pay up money than have the whole embarrassing apology on the cover,” says my first source.

“But man, you need to be careful on how you write this story because you do not want to upset anyone,” says my deep throat and I just rolled my eyes mina.

This isn’t the first time a reputable weekly publication finds itself in hot waters after publishing medical records of a prominent public figure, well, except that Bonang insists the medical records are not hers. In 2007, the late Dr Manto Tshabalala-Msimang’s medical records, Minister of Health at the time, were published in the Sunday Times and the paper titled their story as follows: “Manto’s hospital booze binge” with a subsequent headline the following week reading “Manto – a drunk and a thief”. In the first article, the paper detailed how the now late Minister allegedly jumped the queue to receive a liver transplant and ordered to be served Woolworths food, had wine and allegedly got drunk while on her hospital bed.

The matter saw the paper being sued and tried to fight the matter in court. However, medical records of any given individual, be it a celebrity or a politician, are a private matter as it isn’t like a cheating or corruption scandal. Medical records are most definitely a no go zone area. The paper had to settle the matter out of court with the Minister and you can just imagine how much they paid her since they never apologised.

In breaking the press code, pushing the boundaries and reporting on a private matter, the story must be in the public interest. Also, there is a difference between what interests the public and public interest. The latter cannot be defined by what interests the dumbed down masses. Some trivial celebrity gossip can hardly be public interest, unless otherwise.

The Queen B

If I was the Drum magazine, I was gonna write the apology on the cover and have Bonang on the cover as a lead. I would write the apology very prominently but do it on my own terms. This is what I would do: I would assign an unbiased media academic or practitioner, who would interview the journalist who wrote the story, interview the editor about how the decision to publish the story was made and very importantly, get the so called megastar Bonang Matheba’s comment on the whole thing. I would continue to ask the writer of the apology article to give his or her expert analysis of the whole saga especially because Bonang insists the medical records are not hers. Then in my editorial (if I was the editor) I would ask my readers to make up their minds.

For now, we are waiting to hear what the matter between the lawyers of the two parties would reach an agreement or not and hopefully, if a settlement is reached, my sources will be very benevolent with information so I can update you.

Wise people often say admitting you are wrong [even if you are not] is a sign of strength.

Follow me on Twitter: @TheRealMakisto




13 Comments

bananasplit
05 Mar 2013 11:27

I think they should apologize. It only makes sense for the nurse to be fired whether or not they are Bonangs becoz it's a breach of patient confidentiality. I just think they making a big deal. Drum has run a n umber of dodgy stories so I think Khosi is trying to prove a point engekho. She will waste money and who is she to question the pres ombudsman. What a lack of respect so what Drum is a law unto itself how shallow.

Pastry
05 Mar 2013 11:34

Wise people often say admitting you are wrong [even if you are not] is a sign of strength

One can only wait to see how this whole saga unfolds. So the nurse was fired...mmhh

Pastry
05 Mar 2013 11:37

Woman who leaked the med records...so she might not be a nurse afterall

Cande
05 Mar 2013 13:39

I still cant believe there are people willing to risk their jobs by licking such confidential information. Anyway this case is about to get interesting, thank God Makisto has sources in high places .lol

c carter
05 Mar 2013 22:28

I dnt c ani reason 4 drum to apologise to bonang if its nt true she would let it go.just bcs truth hurts she's complaining

TheLady
06 Mar 2013 09:40

Imagine being jobless coz you are an unnamed source in a story that's been forgotten.

carino
06 Mar 2013 14:35

LOL @  "says my third source"

makisto
06 Mar 2013 22:42

Wa kula wena Carino

mbulela
06 Mar 2013 23:19

Whether they apologize or not, the 'truth' is that the story was true.

Cande
07 Mar 2013 10:41

lol did i spell leaking like that? LOL

bankroll
07 Mar 2013 16:16

I bet you these guys will pay her. I mean they are willing to dish money on celeb weddings and exclusives so I dont think they will mind paying her whatever amount. To them this is far better than apologising

VusiK
07 Mar 2013 18:11

@Cande ...

Drum sources can come lick my confidential information anytime, LMBAO !!!

zam.ngcobo
14 Mar 2013 14:26

Mbulela why are u so sure that the story was true?


Only TVSA members can reply to this thread. Click here to login or register.






LATEST ARTICLES

New on TV today: Thursday 16 May 2024

Docuseries School Ties begins on M-Net and S3 documents The Black American Fight for Freedom.


New! Jhanak Teasers - May 2024

For Jhanak, dance is the breath of her life.


Suidooster Teasers - June 2024

Kate finds a serviette with another girl's number in Riaan's pocket. Naysty.


New on TV today: Wednesday 15 May 2024

Netflix uncovers Ashley Madison: Sex, Lies & Scandal and Britcom Cheaters begins on S3.


Renewed! Generations: The Legacy Season 10 is a go

Disaster averted with an update from series co-producer Human Stark.


Generations: The Legacy Teasers - June 2024

Will Fikile approve her employee’s undercover investigation? And a chance meeting in a lift leads to an unexpected kiss.


Muvhango Teasers - June 2024

James unwittingly gives Azwindini crucial information, and Azwindini hires a P.I.


New on TV today: Tuesday 14 May 2024

HISTORY revisits The Guilty Innocent and two reality shows return on VIA.


Baby Reindeer Richard Gadd's biggest mistake

Richard's alter ego Donny made some humdingers but this was the ultimate. The key to it all.


Die Put 4 Teasers - June 2024

Yikes. Yamac has no idea who he is and what's happening around him.

LATEST SITE ACTIVITY


More activity at TVSA Central



LATEST SOAPIE TEASERS



LATEST SOAPIE TEASERS





×
×

You browser doesn't have Flash, Silverlight, Gears, BrowserPlus or HTML5 support.