SOUTH AFRICA'S TV WEBSITE
SIGN IN SEARCH MENU
SOUTH AFRICA'S TV WEBSITE


Does it still exist

Written by GML from the blog What happened to being original? on 26 Feb 2009
Favourite this post


TVSA is popular to celebraties even though they say they hate it.

I was listening to Metro( dont ask me why) and I heard Sakina Kamwendo( not sure of her name),(she goes on after Robert Marawa) say her topic would be Lobola.

SAkina Kamwendo is the presenter for Melting Pot after Roberts's sport show. Anyway as I was listening i told my man that I wouldnt be surprised if she read an article on TVSA about this topic.

To my surprise, she said she researched this topic and came across an article on the "internet" about Lobolo. She proceeded to read the article and it was the exact article that one of our bloggers (Dimago) wrote about yesterday.
She even made reference to the lobolaonline website.

This made me wonder- shouldn't  people who are supposed writers have their own creative ideas? instead of taking other people ideas and using as plain and unedited like that?

I must say though the show was nice as she had Prof Mkhize who is the founder of some cultural/traditional organisation.
He explain very well the concept of lobolo and what it meant in the olden days.

What are your views on this? It's not the first time I heard someone talk about an article on TVSA without even mentioning TVSA as his/her source.

I found it quite annoying because they make the shows or ideas seem like their own even though Bloggers wrote the article.
It also made me think, If you're gonna read an article on radio shouldn't they also read our replies as they are part of the articles?

She wanted people to call in with their views and questions- we had our views but she didnt voice them.

So are these so called "original" people still original or have they lost all the creative bones in their bodies?



43 Comments

TheLady
26 Feb 2009 08:28

I also laughed when I heard her read it, Maybe poets (Miss mazwai wink, wink, nudge , nudge) can find some inspiration here-when they do their research.

ngwana
26 Feb 2009 08:37

This place is a gold mine, even i have stolen topics from here before.

ngwana
26 Feb 2009 08:37

Meant to say "borrowed topics from here"

Toxic
26 Feb 2009 08:41

big of you to admit to your 'borrowing" ngwana.

i don't ahve a provlem with the act of stealing so much as i have with them not crediting their source. THAT is despicable in my books!

andi01
26 Feb 2009 09:09

We need to stand up against this, its wrong and undermines our creativity, this is plagiarism at its best and wont be tolerated.

GML
26 Feb 2009 09:17

That's what i thought too Andi. They should at least ask our permission before using our work. Just to reply on the blog and ask-

Toxic
26 Feb 2009 09:36

this is just sooooooo wrong, on soooo many levels. i'm annoyed.

awelani
26 Feb 2009 09:38

is there a way of exposing these copy-cats??

awelani
26 Feb 2009 09:40

can we(mjj) report this lady to Mr Mabena...lol

Sana Lwam
26 Feb 2009 09:43

We should actually call in the studio and expose them on air.

felfel
26 Feb 2009 09:45

Y not call the station when they busy discussing our articles, and politely say  on air .."actually this topic was discussed yesterday (or whenever) on a website called TVSA and the view was.......blah blah blah) " that should put the presenter on the spot right there for not crediting her sources...

TheLady
26 Feb 2009 10:01

Felfel-topics get discussed every where all the time- why not " Funny because I wrote an article on my blog with the exact same words as the one you just read, what a coincidence"

mjj
26 Feb 2009 10:05

I don't listen to Metro Awe

Cody
26 Feb 2009 10:21

It is not on period!

awelani
26 Feb 2009 10:22

hi cody ***waving**

myname
26 Feb 2009 10:23

Ok im not gonna say she did a right thing but guys we all inspired by individuals, and to me its a bonus. You should credit yourself. BTW Dimago should to do that. Some they see us as a bunch of crazy children who got nothing to do but trashing/gossiping about them. But still that child can come up with something that will build or inspire you. So lets stand up for Dimago, bloggers & their interesting replies. Lets give them a loud of applause. One day someone will see there is a talent here. 

Just my 2cent so DONTS bite my head

awelani
26 Feb 2009 10:24

LOL @ DONTS....

Cody
26 Feb 2009 10:33

hi maAWWWZAAAAAAA!! missed you girl!!

Cande
26 Feb 2009 10:34

wasnt Mabena fired? or didnt he resign??

awelani
26 Feb 2009 10:34

can u get ur behind to gmail?  MaCodss,,,

One and Only
26 Feb 2009 10:35

I think we should look at the time frame between the TVSA article and the talk show before we can make any assumptions. Aren't the Presenters submitting their topics to someone at the station prior to going on air? Is it seconds, minutes, hours or days in advance?

If you were the same presenter would you risk your reputation by going on air with someone else's work without crediting that individual? Even worse knowing that the article is from TVSA. Knowing TVSA members would you dare do such a thing?

What are the probabilities that the presenter and the blogger came across the same information when doing their research? Was Prof Mkhize called on the same day of the show or was appointment made in advance? 

How do you classify views as that of someone, if I have the same views about AIDS as you, do I own those views?

Cande
26 Feb 2009 10:39

LOL!!!!

Sana Lwam
26 Feb 2009 10:42

Interesting

awelani
26 Feb 2009 10:44

LOL....

Dimago
26 Feb 2009 10:46

Oh my, do you think i can sue Sakina? I smell a lawsuit coming....LOL

GML
26 Feb 2009 10:58

One and Only
The topic was the same day as Dimago's article. Even if it was discussed with the producer a long time ago before airing it, she should have mention who the source was. It's simple.
How do you classify views as that of someone, if I have the same views about AIDS as you, do I own those views?
It's not the same thing. If i write an article that you thought of writing but never got around to writing it, it's my intellectual property. We can think the same things but what we do counts more.
Dimago wrote it first and she used it after the fact.

felfel
26 Feb 2009 11:05

Wats the difference there Lady ?????

Ms. Jay
26 Feb 2009 11:05

LOL Dimags - you go girl!!!! wow hey, I would be flattered not necessarily angry.....

Toxic
26 Feb 2009 11:05

One and only: 

To my surprise, she said she researched this topic and came across an article on the "internet" about Lobolo. She proceeded to read the article and it was the exact article that one of our bloggers (Dimago) wrote about yesterday

answers the timeline question and opinion issue u raise.

TheLady
26 Feb 2009 11:10

 felfel-you were extra nice...

Ms. Jay
26 Feb 2009 11:13

Dimago - already thinking of making a killing...hehehehe go for it my friend!

Dimago
26 Feb 2009 11:14

Bathong, any lawyers here....GML you can be the star witness...

Jael i am not angry, just amused i guess

sjura
26 Feb 2009 11:24

I can be ur lawyer DI..

Ms. Jay
26 Feb 2009 11:32

Be proud of yourself - since you going to win this case - can i borrow R500? hehehehehe....

JuneRose
26 Feb 2009 11:46

Maybe One and Only (Sakina Kamwendo) ke yena presenter eo, why ae twanela so. or the presenter was you Dimago. lol.

Dimago
26 Feb 2009 11:52

Maybe One and Only (Sakina Kamwendo) ke yena presenter eo, why ae twanela so. or the presenter was you Dimago. lol.
JuneRose i think you are onto something...but as for me being the presenter ...ROTFLMBBAO!!!

Sjura, i'll be calling you tonight. Jael i'll give u the R500

Ms. Jay
26 Feb 2009 11:56

Junerose - you may just be right hey...will pm you my bank details dimags

Lessie
26 Feb 2009 12:38

To my surprise, she said she researched this topic and came across an article on the "internet" about Lobolo. She proceeded to read the article and it was the exact article that one of our bloggers (Dimago) wrote about yesterday. 

I found it quite annoying because they make the shows or ideas seem like their own even though Bloggers wrote the article.

My understanding here is that she was honest about the work not being hers. She spoke of the info/article being sourced from the internet. She probabbly should have mentioned TVSA, but she did not at any point make an impression that this was her own creativity. Neways, every company has its policy, what if it does not allow them to specifically state the source (just thinking out loud).

GML
26 Feb 2009 12:45

Nonsense, if she was reading it from a book she would have said the title of the book and who the author was. The Author in this case is Dimago who deserves to be mentioned

KeleFabulous
26 Feb 2009 12:52

D pls don't forget me when you're rich and famous :)

people will always pass other people's work as their own. the least the woman should have done was to acknowledge the author and/or site. it's not enough that she said she was researching and came across it.

GML
26 Feb 2009 12:53

Nonsense, if she was reading it from a book she would have said the title of the book and who the author was. The Author in this case is Dimago who deserves to be mentioned

TheLady
26 Feb 2009 13:59

And not forgeting that this was her only reference.
Big ups to VVO-his voice took me back to my childhood days

Krazy boss
05 Sep 2009 03:28

Thats the south african dream to steal 4rm one another inorda to survive in dis fucked up industry its sick n that presenter is an asshole for takin credit for wats nt hers that *bleep!* head


Only TVSA members can reply to this thread. Click here to login or register.






LATEST ARTICLES

New on TV today: Saturday 27 April

kykNET documents 30 Years of Democracy and the 2024 Metro FM Music Awards air live on SABC1.


Diepe Waters Teasers - May 2024

Gross out alert! The source of the mysterious illness plaguing the swimmers might be right under their noses.


Titli Teasers - May 2024

Titli inadvertently hurts Garv while he attempts to be romantic.


Anupama Teasers - May 2024

Anupama asks Pakhi to care for the Shahs, but Pakhi refuses, stating she won't be their maid.


Imlie Teasers - May 2024

Imlie feels uneasy when Agastya finds her diary filled with thoughts about him.


Gqeberha: The Empire 2 Teasers - May 2024

Nomaflower is forced to bury her love, Stokkie's life hangs in the balance and Lulama receives a letter.


New on TV today: Friday 26 April

SABC2 travels Around the World in 80 Ways and Disney+ tells The Bon Jovi Story.


Summertide character portrait: Tanya van Graan as Charlie

She's an influential new character who has the hotts for who?


My Desire Teasers - May 2024

Kaashvi discovers Arjun in an embarrassing situation and assists him in resolving it.


Trailer, details on local schoolboy sexual abuse docuseries School Ties

"If anyone's paying more attention to your child than you, you have a problem."

LATEST SITE ACTIVITY


More activity at TVSA Central



LATEST SOAPIE TEASERS



LATEST SOAPIE TEASERS





×
×

You browser doesn't have Flash, Silverlight, Gears, BrowserPlus or HTML5 support.