SOUTH AFRICA'S TV WEBSITE
SIGN IN SEARCH MENU
SOUTH AFRICA'S TV WEBSITE


Idols Top 7 performs with the Choir

Written by Tazteeq from the blog Opinion Ramp on 21 Oct 2013
Favourite this post


The competition is heating up on the Idols stage and six contenders sit between the winner and the big prize. The Top 7 took to stage in a choir-theme which got the contenders making tedious song choices, and got me worried if those kids haven’t heard of Mariah Carey and R Kelly songs which are fitted for choir backings. Or maybe the Idols team gave them a stringent song list to choose from? Anyway, let’s look at who brought the brunt and who dropped the ball.

While everyone went dull and lull Zoe brought her guns out to stage and exploded into an incredible showcase, proving yet again that a voice isn’t the only tool one needs to win over viewers. She took on the Jackson Five’s “Can you feel it” and brought the house own. Talk about saving the best for last. 



Bunny Majaja was my second favourite, with her rendition of the old-school Beatles classic “Let it be”. She handled the song so delicate, and the dramatic choral complement added the spice to it. As far as performances stand, Bunny shouldn’t be in the bottom two this week and so is Zoe.

Sonke was my third favourite with Jimmy Cliff’s “Many rivers to cross.” Although the song fell flat due to its unpopular nature, Sonke’s vocals were point on. No vayi-vayis and exaggerated vibratos, his voice is definitely the one to be reckoned with. The performance had judge Randal Abrahams citing “I see you going very far in this competition”, which the young humble Sowetan received with a nod. 



Teen favourite Brenden’s performance was the fourth best. He took on Josh Groban’s “You raise me up” and fiddled with it to stamp his signature to it. Unfortunately it also fell flat, but the highly popular contender held the high notes and ran with them to the end, yet to another of Gareth’s mock. It felt like Gareth and Randal had switched bodies as Mr Cliff found all song choices bleak.

Musa’s version of Anthony Hamilton’s “Pass me over” felt like a gospel worship item in a church service. Musa possibly has the best voices in the competition. He has power, control and a distinct tone which could make any live performance unforgettable but he always skews towards gospel which ultimately makes him sound the same in every song. He is a tough contender, but he needs a quick change of approach to songs. 



Christina’ star is losing the glow - FAST. I don’t know if she is making BAD song choices, but it seemed like she was on the right track when the competition started. Her rendition of Alicia Keys’ “Falling” was painful to the ears. Girl needs to pull up her socks or else she’ll be next to bite the dust. 


After Christalene’s first audition, I was routing for her to make the Top 10 and when she made it I couldn’t be any happier. But I’m slowly feeling like I made the worst mistake rooting for her to start with. She sang Aretha Franklin’s “(You make me feel like) a Natural woman” and although she was on good key with the choir, she did nothing with the song. The song has been sang by almost every female singer who exist and each one has put their signature to it, but Christalene didn’t. She was my weakest link this week. 


Did you vote? Who are rooting for? Who came up best for you? Who might go home?



18 Comments

Favoured
21 Oct 2013 13:38

TheLady
21 Oct 2013 13:44

Christina fell...along with her song.

Even my favourite Sonke didnt impress me.

Ms Opinionated
21 Oct 2013 13:46

Nice review @ Tazteeq

Bunny was the perfromance of the night for me, she redeemed herself after last week.

Zoe is a perfromer of note, I like her energy and the effort she puts in her perfromances

Sonke- remains winning, has been consistent. I am still waiting for him to move from good to GREAT thou! 

Brenden- now this one i just think he is taking chances with his popularity. He can sing but there is something a bit relaxed about him esp in terms of song choices. 

Musa- great voice but he sounded flat last night

Christina- who does that song by Alica thou?? with her direct interpretation??!! 

Crystalene- needs to go! 

My top 3- Sonke, Bunny and Musa

sanell
21 Oct 2013 13:52

@Tazteeq u took the words right out of my mouth, i agree with u. Voting for Zoe till 10pm today.

Nunumsi
21 Oct 2013 14:19

Christalene & Christina must go home. Zoe is the performer yes but I'm not convinced about her voice. My top 5 - Sonke, Brenden, Bunny, Musa & Zoe. My winner is Sonke.

Lovers25
21 Oct 2013 14:29

Brenden's pitching was all wrong, His good looking young man i jst wonder if his music will sell should he be the nxt Idol coz 4 me his really not the greatest of the 7 remaining.
Sonke: WOW young man his humbleness and hungry for the glory shows off week in and out i luvedhis perfomance last night.
Bunny: MY FAVOURITE OF THE NIGHT
Zoe performace wise she was good vocally not tht good.
Crystalene: Truth be told she is fading away slowly bt surely. i dnt feel her 
Christina: from the 1st note of that Alicia song it was WRONG.................
Musa i ddint see his perfomance on the nyt.

Unathi shes always hearing great things from these hopefully, an honest is wat these guys need to improve. no need to say there were "moments" which were good etc

Favoured
21 Oct 2013 14:31

zoe has a unique voice

Darren24
21 Oct 2013 14:57

That was by far one of the worst episodes this season! As expected, most people fell flat with the dull, boring song choices. Even Brenden was quite dodgy and there were parts in the song where his performance verged on screaming. Musa fails to excite me and just comes across as dull every week; even if his voice is good. Crystalene & Christina lost the plot once again and sounded flat and dreary. Sonke chose one of the worst songs of the night, but he did alright. Bunny & Zoe were my favorites also because they actually performed and didn't resort to being boring. But overall the night sucked! And the choir wasn't helping much.. Where's last season's choir!?

Vesa
21 Oct 2013 15:09

What a boring show it was! Tjeerrrr......I'm not voting this week! Hopefully next week will be better

Amy M
21 Oct 2013 15:32

My votes went to both Bunny and Brenden (most votes to Brenden coz he is my homeboy). But i must admit that his song choice was oh so boring. I would have loved to hear him sing R.Kelly's Sign of a Victory song. As for Christina, oh my word that girl is so full of herself, mxh talking about having the full package, oh please, those skinny legs of hers (sticks). Her performance was terrible. I think its time for her to pack her bags and go home. Zoe's performance was full of energy but as for the singing , nope. She was sreaming throughout the entire song.

Timone
21 Oct 2013 15:47

I also think Crystalene was the weakest performance this week.  I suspect Zoe could be the dark horse of this competition.

Name here
21 Oct 2013 16:37

Brendan was AWFUL. He and Christina were the worst of the night. I'm still shocked that she and Crystalene are still in the competition. Crystalene had a great audition and awesome rendition of "Moves Like Jagger" in the theatre round. What ever happened to that girl? Top 3: Zoe, Musa & Sonke.

wonderlad
21 Oct 2013 16:46

Hmm I liked Sonke and Bunny this week. Will agree with Gareth that song choice is dull. Didn't think that Crystalene or Christina were that bad vocally. Zoe brought great energy but her singing was not that good. Musa is boring to me.

lalah
21 Oct 2013 17:31

"Brenden- now this one i just think he is taking chances with his popularity. He can sing but there is something a bit relaxed about him esp in terms of song choices" Couldn't agree more @Ms Opinionated Actually da entire episode was just off. Zoe en Bunny did entertain though

Sobza
21 Oct 2013 19:05

I have been voting Sonke every hour...I careless about the rest. It was a boring show until Zoe took to the stage

Pastry
22 Oct 2013 09:26

I sure agree that Zoe's performance got my attention but i must say i wasnt entertained by it at all. 
Bunny did it for me on Sunday, she got most of my votes for that!
BMS three guys were all average. 
The other remaining two C ladies were not impressive at all. What they delivered doest even qualify to be on the top 7 idols stage!

Now...between the two C girls, one must pack her backs tonight!

Favoured
22 Oct 2013 09:51

i loved their Roar performance shem

Mbunju
23 Oct 2013 11:46

wow! de SA's indeed hv talent, it's been a wonderful show I hope nxt tym we wil hv much beta dan dis, but it was lovely, gr8, disireable.


Only TVSA members can reply to this thread. Click here to login or register.






LATEST ARTICLES

Two former Miss South Africa's in Duma Ndlovu's Queen Modjadji

It scares us. Schmodels in a historical drama - how "Method" will they be? But okay, let's not be judgy and see.


Elif 5 Teasers - May 2024

Melek's had enough of Figen's insults. Is she honest about it? Yes! When you need to fight you must fight.


Chrysalis 2 Teasers - May 2024

Nalan shoots her magazine cover and her style has completely changed.


New on TV today: Thursday 18 April 2024

More Plaasjapies pitch up on kykNET and BBC Earth travels Ancient Egypt by Train.


17 shows with Mzansi in the title - name them!

So you consider yourself a big stuff TV buff? Let's see. Take the test.


House of Zwide 3 Teasers - May 2024

Are they a throuple? No. Soka and Ona and Mampho are all in it together but not in that way.


New on TV today: Wednesday 17 April

Feud: Capote vs. The Swans drops on Disney+ and Travel Channel dives into Spooked Scotland.


Top Shows on TV: March 2024

Ka-ching! The biggest winner in Skeem Saam's move to 19h30: Sibongile & The Dlaminis which takes DStv's No.1 spot by a whopping margin.


New on TV today: Tuesday 16 April

The only new show tonight is the return of Car S.O.S. on National Geographic.


Renewed! My Brother's Keeper lands 260-episode Season 2

It began with a cautious 130-eps order and now it's been signed for a year.

LATEST SITE ACTIVITY


More activity at TVSA Central



LATEST SOAPIE TEASERS



LATEST SOAPIE TEASERS





×
×

You browser doesn't have Flash, Silverlight, Gears, BrowserPlus or HTML5 support.